Crime: Consequence and Rehabilitation

A meaningful response to those guilty of committing a crime either juvenile or adult must contain two elements:

Consequence and rehabilitation.

It cannot be consequence nor rehabilitation alone but robust balanced measures of both.

Not hard or soft but both hard and soft.

A hard response because we care about the standards that underpin our society and a soft response because you care about the individual and want to help reconnect that person positively to their community.

Any effective punishment of course must be appropriate to the crime and not designed to humiliate. The intent of any punishment should be to deliver a meaningful response proportionate to the offence and require where possible recompense, apology and repair of the damage to community.

Punishment is justice being seen to be done and by being seen to be done common community values are reinforced.  We should resist any judicial response that creates uncertainty in the mind of a child or an adult that stealing, destruction of public property or the wilful injuring of another member of our community is anything else but wrong.

Punishment marks the boundaries that guide the framing of a cohesive society, this boundary defines the standards that we value and aspire to as a society and individuals.  

A punitive response to a breach signals to the individual in breach that they have fallen short but should also say that they are capable of better choices.  A rehabilitative response is designed to enable them to reach for that standard.

The reality is that people make choices and choices have consequences. By diminishing a punitive approach and emphasising instead the ‘special circumstances’ that caused an offender to offend feeds the idea of ‘victimhood’.  By not affirming the truth that every person is endowed with the dignity of will and capacity the socially and personally damaging choices are validated and personal responsibility explained away. Worse the offenders’ dignity is denied by saying they are powerless to choose otherwise and someone else is to blame.

This approach carries the deceptive and dangerous implication that crime is a societal disease rather than a breach of a moral code; consequently a offender is treated with therapy not punishment.

Once the idea of ‘victimhood’ is introduced the socially damaging actions of an individual are excused leaving the community to clean up the mess and foot the bill while a hand is extended to the offender.

In this scenario right and wrong, good and bad become subjective values rather than objective standards.   Consequentially moral bearings are lost and children and families are confused.

Now we can have a person stab or try to run over a policemen or commit over 50 serious offences and the backstory of the offender becomes the main story rather than the serious breach to community standards and the harm inflicted on victims.    

Recasting the offender as a victim harms the offender by supporting the idea that because they can’t be held responsible for their actions they are somehow incapable of free choice, their humanity is diminished and consigned to a lesser existence as a powerless victim of society.  

For those who believe that strong punishment alone fixes the problem risk damaging an already damaged individual and likely create a greater problem

Those who argue the offender should be treated lightly or absolved of personal responsibility and responsibility for the crime transferred instead to society for creating the problem devalue both the individual and the society they live in.

Yes an offender may have his or her judgment impaired at the time, may have had a very difficult family life or some other condition but deny them an encounter with reality by holding them accountable inflicts further harm on both.

Those who care must come together and work to deliver a tough love response to young offenders.

We need to respond wisely and courageously because every indication is that it is likely to get worse unless we redefine the boundaries to guide our families and communities.

A sound judicial and correction system must aim to both defend community standards and repair the damage to individuals, offenders and victims.

 

Author: terencekennedy

I live in the North of Australia in a city closer to Jakarta than Canberra. My view of the world is flavoured by the easy reminder that Australia's address is within a South East Asian neighbourhood.

One thought on “Crime: Consequence and Rehabilitation”

  1. how hard would it be to use the same approach as the military. as in recruitment and conscription. small teams, positiveness, ownership of you and results of why you are in this position now. hard as in competing with other groups. stick together as a group. may be self sufficiency as in foods and animal husbandry like own chooks for eggs, .. grow vegetables. pride in the group and owner ship of facilities and house work, assist in kitchen and cleaning of barracks and inspections expecting good results. teach personal life skills and education. make signs relating to yesterday is gone and today is where you are at. life choices from this moment on. one fails and the whole group gets punished as in runs or clean-up as in camp tidy up in their spare time. competitive games none contact like rugby as in may degenerate into payback and inju5ry.. persistent bad boys step into the ring and wshake hands before and after. fight fair. excercise and fresh air. councilling sessions where they are encouraged to talk or listen. no blame or put-downs. report if their are. private councilling sessions where they are treated as a person who got on the wrong track. earn the right to leadership and maybe priveleges within the group. …. enough there to kick start your thinking.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s